tributehub

Not to thrilled with this album...some good songs...not a bad album, just kind of drags at parts.....I was so happy to hear David Gilmour when "not now john" came on...I wish he was on this album a bit more. That song and "Fletcher" are probably my fav songs on the album.  I dont know why but "filthy desert" reminds me of something from Monty Python. Its hard for me to get through this whole album. "Southhampton" is also cool.....like I said not a bad album but to much Roger and not enough David and a little to soft sounding....its official I like David more then Roger  ;D

I have read where some people say its a grower and I hope thats what it does for me.....Even through "Not now John" is one of my favs it seems a little out of place on the album.....I'll say this for it....I can see why so many people think its the worst album...but I can also see why many people love it...I know it sounds weird but its true....anyways.....I want to wait till xmas to get the wall....I am trying to get through Ricks "broken dreams" which has been a little tough for me....some of it drags but I like many of the songs...

"Its official,I like David more than Roger"......join the club ;D

It's one of my Floyd favourites, although it's really more of a solo Rog outing. It definitely grew on me.

It grew on me the same way a boil does. ;D I've been trying to get into it since the album was released but to no avail I'm afraid.

This album does nothing for me but it's all horses for courses

I liked it straight away, I love to hear Roger bearing his heart and soul.